When an appliance breaks down or starts acting up, the same question always follows: Should I repair it or replace it? At Fergus Home & Hardware, we are uniquely positioned to give you an honest answer.
With both an experienced Appliance Service Department and a full showroom, our goal is not to sell you something you don't need—it is to help you make the best decision for your home and budget.
Here is how to know when it makes sense to fix what you have and when it is time to start shopping for something new.
Signs That Repair Is Likely Your Best Option
1. Your Appliance Is Under 8 Years Old
Most major appliances are designed to last 9–13 years, depending on use and maintenance. If yours is on the younger end of that range, repairs are often worthwhile.
2. The Repair Cost Is Reasonable
A common rule of thumb: if the repair costs less than 50% of the price of a replacement, it is usually worth fixing. Our service team can diagnose the issue and give you a clear explanation of what is needed. Honest opinions. No guesswork.
3. Some Common, Easily Fixable Problems Include:
- Dishwasher not draining (often just a clogged filter or pump)
- Dryer not heating (typically a bad element — simple fix)
- Refrigerator section not cooling (usually a fan or sensor)
- Washer leaks (commonly worn hoses or seals)
These types of repairs can often extend the life of your appliance for years.
4. You Are Happy With How It Performs
Indicators That Replacement May Be the Smarter Choice
1. It Is Near the End of Its Lifespan
If your appliance is 10–15+ years old, especially with frequent repairs, replacement often makes more sense than continuing to invest in fixes.
2. Repairs Are Becoming Frequent
If you are calling for service more often or facing multiple issues at once, that is a sign the appliance is wearing out.
3. The Repair Is Costly or Parts Are Hard to Find
Older models may require expensive parts or have limited availability. In these cases, putting money toward a new appliance can be a smarter investment.
4. You Are Missing Out on Efficiency & Features
- Energy Star certification that can cut utility costs by 10–50%
- Water-saving features (some new washers use 50% less water)
- Quieter operation
- Modern conveniences like steam cycles, flexible storage, and smart home integration
Replacing an outdated appliance can lower utility costs and improve daily convenience.
- Appliance under 8 years + repair under 50% of replacement cost = Repair
- Appliance 10+ years + costly repair + frequent issues = Replace
- Not sure? Call us for an honest assessment.
The Fergus Home & Hardware Advantage: Sales and Service
What sets Fergus Home & Hardware apart? We are your neighbors, and we handle both sides of the equation with honesty and expertise.
Honest Service Evaluations
Our local service department with experienced technicians will assess your appliance and give you straightforward advice. If a repair makes sense, we will fix it. If replacement is the better route, we will tell you that too.
Guided Appliance Shopping
If it is time for something new, our appliance sales team will help you find the right fit by asking the right questions:
- How many people does the appliance serve?
- How do you use it day-to-day?
- What do you like or dislike about your current model?
We match appliances to your lifestyle, space, and budget—not just what is popular.
Delivery, Installation & Ongoing Support
Our in-house delivery and installation team ensures your new appliance is set up correctly, and if you ever need service down the road, you already know who to call.
Still Not Sure?
You do not have to decide on your own. Whether you are dealing with a frustrating breakdown or planning ahead for an upgrade, our team is here to help you weigh your options with confidence.
Call our service department at 218-998-5070 or stop by our showroom at 1005 North Tower Road. We are here to help you make the right choice for your home.